All songs written by Bill Berry, Peter Buck, Mike Mills, and Michael Stipe, except where noted

Disc one

"Living Well Is the Best Revenge" (from Accelerate) (Buck, Mills, Stipe) – 4:07
"Second Guessing" (from Reckoning) – 2:58
"Letter Never Sent" (from Reckoning) – 3:51
"Staring Down the Barrel of the Middle Distance" (Previously unreleased) (Buck, Mills, Stipe) – 4:11
"Disturbance at the Heron House" (from Document) – 3:41
"Mr. Richards" (from Accelerate) (Buck, Mills, Stipe) – 4:17
"Houston" (from Accelerate) (Buck, Mills, and Stipe) – 1:54
"New Test Leper" (from New Adventures in Hi-Fi) – 5:26
"Cuyahoga" (from Lifes Rich Pageant) – 4:22
"Electrolite" (from New Adventures in Hi-Fi) – 4:03
"Man-Sized Wreath" (from Accelerate) (Buck, Mills, and Stipe) – 3:09
"So. Central Rain" (from Reckoning) – 3:44
"On the Fly" (Previously unreleased) (Buck, Mills, Stipe) – 5:01
"Maps and Legends" (from Fables of the Reconstruction) – 3:10
"Sitting Still" (from Murmur) – 3:42
"Driver 8" (from Fables of the Reconstruction) – 3:44
"Horse to Water" (from Accelerate) (Buck, Mills, and Stipe) – 2:45
"I'm Gonna DJ" (from Accelerate) (Buck, Mills, and Stipe) – 2:16
"Circus Envy" (from Monster) – 4:27
"These Days" (from Lifes Rich Pageant) – 4:53

Disc two

"Drive" (from Automatic for the People) – 4:49
"Feeling Gravitys Pull" (from Fables of the Reconstruction) – 5:10
"Until the Day Is Done" (from Accelerate) (Buck, Mills, and Stipe) – 4:07
"Accelerate" (from Accelerate) (Buck, Mills, and Stipe) – 3:35
"Auctioneer (Another Engine)" (from Fables of the Reconstruction) – 3:38
"Little America" (from Reckoning) – 3:11
"1,000,000" (from Chronic Town) – 3:28
"Disguised" (early version of "Supernatural Superserious" from Accelerate) (Buck, Mills, and Stipe) – 3:20
"The Worst Joke Ever" (from Around the Sun) (Buck, Mills, and Stipe) – 3:42
"Welcome to the Occupation" (from Document) – 2:47
"Carnival of Sorts (Boxcars) (from Chronic Town) – 4:09
"Harborcoat" (from Reckoning) – 4:16
"Wolves, Lower" (from Chronic Town) – 4:33
"I've Been High" (from Reveal) (Buck, Mills, and Stipe) – 3:40
"Kohoutek" (from Fables of the Reconstruction) – 4:12
"West of the Fields" (from Murmur) (Jerry Ayers, Berry, Buck, Mills, and Stipe) – 4:13
"Pretty Persuasion" (from Reckoning) – 4:23
"Romance" (from Eponymous) – 3:31
"Gardening at Night" (from Chronic Town) – 4:16